SMN forum votes on 50 Greatest Death Metal albums[views:11283][posts:68]___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 4:51pm - BornSoVile ""] thread here - http://www.smnnews.com/board/showthread.php?t=170685 01. Suffocation - “Effigy of the Forgotten” 02. Suffocation - “Pierced From Within” 03. Cynic - “Focus” 04. Gorguts - “The Erosion of Sanity” 05. Cryptopsy - “None So Vile” 06. Death - “Human” 07. Spawn of Possession - “Noctambulant” 08. Death - “Individual Thought Patterns” 09. Spawn of Possession - “Cabinet” 10. Lykathea Aflame - “Elvenefris” 11. Immolation - “Here In After” 12. Cannibal Corpse - “Tomb of the Mutilated” 13. Disgorge - “Consume The Forsaken” 14. Psycroptic - “The Scepter of the Ancients” 15. Cannibal Corpse - “The Bleeding” 16. Morbid Angel - “Covenant” 16. Gorguts - “Considered Dead” 18. Gorguts - “Obscura” 19. Carcass - “Necroticism: Descanting The Insalubrious” 20. Origin - “Informis Infinitas Inhumanitas” 21. Defeated Sanity - “Psalms of the Moribund” 22. Death - “The Sound of Perseverance” 23. Immolation - “Close To A World Below” 24. Augury - “Concealed” 25. Death - “Symbolic” 26. Morbid Angel - “Blessed Are The Sick” 27. Deicide - “Legion” 28. Immolation - “Failures For Gods” 29. Deicide - “Deicide” 30. Malevolent Creation - “Retribution” 31. Morbid Angel - “Altars of Madness” 32. Cryptopsy - “Whisper Supremacy” 33. Atheist - “Unquestionable Presence” 34. Wormed - “Planesphaerium” 35. Obituary - “Cause of Death” 36. Carcass - “Heartwork” 36. Suffocation - “Despise The Sun” 38. Immolation - “Dawn of Possession” 38. Necrophagist - “Onset of Putrefaction” 38. Deicide - “Once Upon The Cross” 41. Incantation - “Onward To Golgotha” 41. Iniquity - “Serenadium” 41. Cannibal Corpse - “Vile” 44. Carcass - “Symphonies of Sickness” 44. Death - “Leprosy” 44. Decrepit Birth - “…And Time Begins” 47. Autopsy - “Mental Funeral” 48. Dismember - “Like An Everflowing Stream” 49. Morbid Angel - “Formulas Fatal To The Flesh” 50. Demilich - “Nesphithe” 50. Broken Hope - “Loathing“ |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 4:55pm - fleshfries ""] If it were up to me, these would be in no specific order. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 4:56pm - BornSoVile ""] I have serious issues with no Dying Fetus or Krisiun. No Grave!? Lack of Dismember!!! No love on either of the first two Goratory albums, along with Eternal Suffering and Scattered Remnants. No Mortal Decay, fuck that! DISINCARNATE YOU FUCKING COCKSUCKERS. Broken Hope and Demilich should have been at least in the top 15. I'm done. |
| _________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 4:57pm - brian_dc ""] agree with it or not...that's an awesome list of albums |
| ____________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:00pm - ZJD ""] No to so much of this. 1) Autopsy appears but no Severed Survival 2) Entombed is completely absent. Left Hand Path should be in the top 20 at least. 3) Suffocation does not belong in the top 2, let alone in both. Ehhhhhh. Ever top anything list I've ever read has bummed me out. |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:02pm - Beorht-Dana ""] Necroticism should have been in the top 10 at least. I also agree that no Dismember album is a disgrace. Also, what is Disgorge doing so high on the list? |
| _________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:04pm - brian_dc ""] I always just read these things in no specific order...such a ridiculous thing to do...rank music...something entirely based on personal opinions |
| ____________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:09pm - ZJD ""] BornSoVile said: Lack of Dismember!!! Beorht-Dana said: I also agree that no Dismember album is a disgrace. 48. Dismember - “Like An Everflowing Stream” |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:17pm - Mike_Giallo ""] I think only about 4 of these CDs should have made the list. The rest are completely bogus. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:26pm - BornSoVile ""] ZJD said:BornSoVile said: Lack of Dismember!!! Beorht-Dana said: I also agree that no Dismember album is a disgrace. 48. Dismember - “Like An Everflowing Stream” NUMBER 48!??!! |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:27pm - BornSoVile ""] when it comes to Disgorge, Cranial Impalement is all I fucking need. |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:39pm - the_reverend ""] morbid angel not in the top 10, failed. athiest piece of time? failed. unless I just didn't see it, im driving no possessed? failed. lot of really good cds though. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 5:40pm - BornSoVile ""] 3 Gorguts albums in the top 20 is something I definately agree with. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 6:37pm - BornSoVile ""] total lack of anything James Murphy on there too. |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 7:00pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] Totally incomplete list. |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 7:00pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] ENTOMBED, CARNAGE, UNLEASHED, GRAVE, DEMIGOD?! |
| __________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 7:34pm - jere nli ""] effigy of the forgotten definetly deserves to be in the top ten, one of my all time favorite albums period. Everyone is so all about pierced, dont get me wrong its a great record but effigy was their peak. Scattered remnants, what a great band that was too. I def agree with left hand path, and broken hope. how the fuck does broken hope not make this list? |
| _________________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 7:43pm - corpus_colostomy ""] erosion of sanity is soooo fucking good . |
| ________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 9:49pm - phillip ""] jere nli said: effigy of the forgotten definetly deserves to be in the top ten, one of my all time favorite albums period. Everyone is so all about pierced, dont get me wrong its a great record but effigy was their peak. Scattered remnants, what a great band that was too. I def agree with left hand path, and broken hope. how the fuck does broken hope not make this list? 50. Broken Hope - “Loathing“ |
| __________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 10:10pm - Dankill ""] This should have been a top 100 list with no specific order. |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 10:13pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] Lists are dumb. Where the fuck is EDGE OF SANITY?! |
| __________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 10:15pm - archaeon ""] this list isn't really meant to be taken seriously. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 8,2007 10:20pm - dreadkill ""] AUTOPSY_666 said:Lists are dumb. Where the fuck is EDGE OF SANITY?! i was wondering that too |
| ______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 10:41am - Yeti ""] what a shitty list. i mean the bands are good, but that is an uneducated "death metal lite" list. |
| ______________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 10:54am - GoatCatalyst ""] How in the Christing FUCK can you even RATIONALIZE placing the vocoder-laced faggotry of Focus (please refer to the demos for the hetero versions of these songs) ahead of Blessed Are The Sick AND Necroticism??? UGH! Jewish liberal media:1 - Non-ZOG-encumbered death metal community: 0 |
| _______________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 10:59am - mortalis nli ""] i like how they have something from the chasm in there. oh, wait... |
| _______________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 11:02am - mortalis nli ""] and amon amarth may be melodic/gay, but i dunno. i think they should be in there. |
| ____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 11:13am - ConquerTheBaphomet ""] I never take these kind of lists seriously because it's all opinion-based. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 11:16am - peteovdom ""] Im surprised no Decapitated, Winds of creation remains one of the most amazing albums, especially considering those guys were like 15 yrs old when they released it |
| __________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 12:28pm - corpus_colostomy ""] winds of creation is a must bro! agreed!! |
| ______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 12:39pm - Yeti ""] mortalis nli said:and amon amarth may be melodic/gay wait what? how the hell is anything Amon Amarth did gay? |
| ______________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 1:31pm - mortalis nli ""] Yeti said:mortalis nli said:and amon amarth may be melodic/gay wait what? how the hell is anything Amon Amarth did gay? twas sarcasm, making fun of the ALL BR00TAL ALL SLAM ALL THE TIME death metal. not that i don't enjoy me some defeated sanity, but i like other stuff, too. |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 1:33pm - the_reverend ""] despise the sun? WTF! no way should that be in there. |
| ____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 1:37pm - MarkFuckingRichards ""] brian_dc said:I always just read these things in no specific order...such a ridiculous thing to do...rank music...something entirely based on personal opinions I agree. Although it still pisses me off that not enough people think that Broken Hope's "Loathing" is the single greatest death metal release of all fucking time. |
| _____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 1:48pm - BobNOMAAMRooney nli ""] I'd put Rebaelliun's Annhilation on that list. |
| _____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 1:48pm - BobNOMAAMRooney nli ""] It would help if I could spell Annihilation |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 2:05pm - NIGGER ""] BornSoVile said:thread here - http://www.smnnews.com/board/showthread.php?t=170685 01. Suffocation - “Effigy of the Forgotten” 02. Suffocation - “Pierced From Within” 04. Gorguts - “The Erosion of Sanity” 05. Cryptopsy - “None So Vile” 06. Death - “Human” 11. Immolation - “Here In After” 16. Morbid Angel - “Covenant” 16. Gorguts - “Considered Dead” 18. Gorguts - “Obscura” 23. Immolation - “Close To A World Below” 26. Morbid Angel - “Blessed Are The Sick” 27. Deicide - “Legion” 28. Immolation - “Failures For Gods” 29. Deicide - “Deicide” 31. Morbid Angel - “Altars of Madness” 33. Atheist - “Unquestionable Presence” 35. Obituary - “Cause of Death” 36. Suffocation - “Despise The Sun” 38. Immolation - “Dawn of Possession” 38. Deicide - “Once Upon The Cross” 41. Incantation - “Onward To Golgotha” 47. Autopsy - “Mental Funeral” 48. Dismember - “Like An Everflowing Stream” 49. Morbid Angel - “Formulas Fatal To The Flesh” 50. Demilich - “Nesphithe” WHITE PEOPLE DON'T KNOW DEATH METAL NO MORE I TOOK OUT THE CRAP AND LEFT THE BEST BLACK POWER |
| ____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 2:09pm - MarkFuckingRichards ""] You forgot to keep in Broken Hope. You are wrong at life. |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 2:16pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] And removing LYKATHEA AFLAME and WORMED is beyond stupid. |
| ____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 2:18pm - MarkFuckingRichards ""] AUTOPSY_666 said:And removing LYKATHEA AFLAME and WORMED is beyond stupid. Truth. |
| ______________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 2:21pm - mortalis nli ""] and you can't leave obituary in there but take out malevolent creation, |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 3:31pm - NIGGER ""] MarkFuckingRichards said:You forgot to keep in Broken Hope. You are wrong at life. DID YOU KNOW BROKEN HOPE USED TO BE AN R&B BAND? THAT'S WHEN THEY WERE GOOD SOME SWINGING GROOVES NOW THEY'RE A MALEVOLENT CREATION IMITATOR A FAKERY OF A FAILURE? WTF BLACK POWER |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 3:32pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] BH > MC |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 3:33pm - NIGGER ""] NIGGA PLEASE MC AT LEAST WAS FRESH BH ARE PLAYA HATING CLONES BLACK POWER |
| ____________________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 3:46pm - MarkFuckingRichards ""] Broken Hope bring the funk. |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 4:04pm - NIGGER ""] YES BUT NOT WELL |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 4:07pm - the_reverend ""] when I clicked this, I thought "nigger's going to comment on the drummer of suffo" he didn't. fail. |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 4:09pm - NIGGER ""] BROTHA, I SAW NO NEED, BECAUSE WE ALL KNOW WHO HAS THE SUPERIOR RHYTHMIC PERCUSSION SKILLS OF ALL THE RACES GOOD THEY GOT A WHITE BOY ON THE VOCALS THOUGH, THAT SHIT HURTS MY THROAT JUST TO THINK ABOUT BUT I APPRECIATE YOUR CONCERN AND WILL TRY NOT TO LET YOU DOWN. THIS IS MY FAVORITE INTERNET FORUM BLACK POWER |
| ________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 4:10pm - c.dead ""] That list makes me want to punch the screen. Suffocation is no where near the best death metal band. I could go on and on on how many should be there and aren't. Lykathea Aflame is on it, which amazes me. Highly underrated band, and ruled when they were called Apalling Spawn as well. Some bands are way to recent (including above mentioned band) to be on it. Spawn of Possession? Are you fucking kidding me? Origin? Wormed??? what the shit are they thinking? |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 6:08pm - Djeez ""] c.dead said:That list makes me want to punch the screen. Suffocation is no where near the best death metal band. I could go on and on on how many should be there and aren't. Lykathea Aflame is on it, which amazes me. Highly underrated band, and ruled when they were called Apalling Spawn as well. Some bands are way to recent (including above mentioned band) to be on it. Spawn of Possession? Are you fucking kidding me? Origin? Wormed??? what the shit are they thinking? Well it's a "favorite album" list, not a "greatests album" list. |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 7:15pm - anonymous ""] the original thread never said "GREATEST" anywhere on it. It was for fun and just everyone's "FAVORITE" albums, that's it. too many people took it way too seriously. |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 7:19pm - the_reverend ""] I really don't think that is true. I think what is true is that this is a very good conversation provoking topic. |
| _______________________________ [Nov 9,2007 9:39pm - Ryan_M ""] BornSoVile said:thread here - http://www.smnnews.com/board/showthread.php?t=170685 01. Suffocation - “Effigy of the Forgotten” 12. Cannibal Corpse - “Tomb of the Mutilated” 16. Morbid Angel - “Covenant” 26. Morbid Angel - “Blessed Are The Sick” 27. Deicide - “Legion” 29. Deicide - “Deicide” 30. Malevolent Creation - “Retribution” 31. Morbid Angel - “Altars of Madness” 41. Incantation - “Onward To Golgotha” 44. Carcass - “Symphonies of Sickness” 44. Death - “Leprosy” 47. Autopsy - “Mental Funeral” These are the only ones on the list I feel are worth mentioning - I could add a couple more that weren't listed. Also: BornSoVile said:total lack of anything James Murphy on there too. #35: Obituary "Cause of Death" James Murphy played on that one. They listed every Death album except Scream Bloody Gore and Spiritual Healing....why SBG wasn't included AT ALL is beyond me. |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 9,2007 11:31pm - BornSoVile ""] Yeah, but James has done alot of other shit other than Obituary....Disincarnate niggah! and Spiritual Healing is the heaviest most nasty Death album ever! |
| _____________________________ [Nov 10,2007 2:30am - OCR ""] cynic death metal please |
| ________________________________ [Nov 10,2007 3:57am - siege ""] 1. it was a fucking favorites list, for our fucking forum. We aren't venerating the classics here, it's what we jam the most. And we decided to include Cynic. So shut up, make your own list to show how "true" you guys are. |
| __________________________________ [Nov 10,2007 9:39am - archaeon ""] siege said:1. it was a fucking favorites list, for our fucking forum. We aren't venerating the classics here, it's what we jam the most. And we decided to include Cynic. So shut up, make your own list to show how "true" you guys are. THANK YOU people are retarded |
| ____________________________________________ [Nov 10,2007 10:09am - eric militianary ""] ZJD said:No to so much of this. 1) Autopsy appears but no Severed Survival 2) Entombed is completely absent. Left Hand Path should be in the top 20 at least. 3) Suffocation does not belong in the top 2, let alone in both. Ehhhhhh. Ever top anything list I've ever read has bummed me out. i agree left hand path is definately one of the best death metal albums ever and every autopsy album should be on there and the bleeding and butchered at birth are better then tomb of the mutilated |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 10,2007 11:29am - niflheim ""] Exclusion of Atrocity's Hallucinations? That should have made the list considering how influential it is. |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 10,2007 11:52am - immortal13 ""] I think they should have kept it as one album per band up there, not a bunch of bands with different albums on the top 50. Plus, The Bleeding sucks in my opinion. |
| _______________________________ [Nov 10,2007 11:57am - Blue ""] c.dead said:That list makes me want to punch the screen. Suffocation is no where near the best death metal band. I could go on and on on how many should be there and aren't. Lykathea Aflame is on it, which amazes me. Highly underrated band, and ruled when they were called Apalling Spawn as well. Some bands are way to recent (including above mentioned band) to be on it. Spawn of Possession? Are you fucking kidding me? Origin? Wormed??? what the shit are they thinking? ah yes, we forgot the number one requirement on this list...NO BANDS UNDER 10 YEARS OF AGE ALLOWED ON TEH LIST LOLZ))))RERTSDFG BECAUSE YOU AER NOT TEH TR)) IF ARE NOT OVAER 40 YEARS OF TEH AGE |
| ____________________________________ [Nov 10,2007 2:48pm - BornSoVile ""] siege said:1. it was a fucking favorites list, for our fucking forum. We aren't venerating the classics here, it's what we jam the most. And we decided to include Cynic. So shut up, make your own list to show how "true" you guys are. That's a noble point and a definate mistake on my behalf. Sorry. Still though, what's the world coming too????? You guys are soft!! :moe: |
| ___________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 10:47am - archaeon ""] this was also set up so your chose you own top 10 favorite DM albums to listen too. thats why there's so many artist repeats Anyone who reads SMN would except a lot of modern tech bands to be on the top of the list because it's most a MODERN death metal forum. I'm surprised Psalms wasn't number 1 haha. |
| _________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 11:32am - NIGGER ""] siege said:1. it was a fucking favorites list, for our fucking forum. We aren't venerating the classics here, it's what we jam the most. And we decided to include Cynic. So shut up, make your own list to show how "true" you guys are. THERE'S NOTHING WRONG WITH BEING GAY FAGGOT BLACK POWER! |
| ________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 3:47pm - siege ""] you are a terrible attempt at a gimmick. |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 4:00pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] Total Posts: 443 = lame troll |
| ________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 6:46pm - NIGGER ""] RACISTS |
| _____________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 6:51pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] [img] |
| ________________________________ [Nov 11,2007 8:11pm - NIGGER ""] THAT'S WHAT THEY KEEP UNDER THE WHITE HOUSE DEAD NIGGERS FUCKING RACE WAR HONKEYS BLACK POWER! |